If I'm reading all your posts correctly, it seems that those defending the paid tutorials are saying that they are more like classes and far more informative and in depth than the general tutorials that Missouri Star offered for free for so long, is that right? If so, my only question is, why did she take the free ones down then? Why not leave those up for the ones who enjoyed them for what they were and let those who needed/wanted more in depth information pay for the lessons? Just a thought.
I too believe different strokes for different folks. No right or wrong here, just what works for you. Also, I happen to love Missouri Star Quilt Co. and often do business with them. They're a great bunch!