I think it is absolutely gorgeous. Maybe you're just accustomed to colorful quilts, and just need to get used to the simplicity of a wholecloth. I just think it is beautiful. You did a wonderful job. What an heirloom! If you DO decided to do another, maybe if you'd like to see the quilting more use an off-white thread, or maybe a varrigated one? GREAT job. We are so proud of you!!